💣 The Hunt for Power: Red Sox Shift Focus to Adding Impact Bat After Gray Trade

The Boston Red Sox have officially pivoted their offseason strategy.¹ Following the successful acquisition of veteran right-hander Sonny Gray from the St. Louis Cardinals, Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow is now aggressively shifting the organization's focus to fortifying the lineup with a middle-of-the-order impact bat.²

The move for Gray gives the Red Sox a much-needed front-line presence, slotting him into the rotation alongside Garrett Crochet and Brayan Bello.³ With the pitching staff bolstered, the mandate is clear: the offense needs an injection of power and consistency to compete in the fiercely competitive American League East in 2026.

---

The Pitching Pivot: Gray Clears the Path

For weeks, the Red Sox had been transparent about their dual priorities: a frontline starting pitcher and a significant offensive upgrade.⁴ The trade for Gray, in which the team only parted with a pair of pitching prospects (Brandon Clarke and Richard Fitts), allows Breslow to dedicate the remaining resources—both financial and in terms of trade chips—entirely to the hitting side.

Gray’s durability (he made every start in 2025) and solid performance (14-8 with a $4.28$ ERA) instantly stabilize a rotation that was often stretched thin last season. This stability has now freed the Red Sox from the necessity of pursuing the top-tier free-agent pitchers, enabling them to pursue a high-priced slugger.

The Shortlist: Who Could Be Heading to Fenway?

The Red Sox's primary target is a right-handed power hitter capable of playing an infield corner or serving as a high-impact designated hitter.⁵ The financial flexibility of the club—sitting approximately $21 million below the competitive balance tax (CBT) threshold before factoring in potential overages—means they can genuinely be in play for any major free agent.⁶

Here are the top names linked to the Red Sox:

1. The Right-Handed Power Surge: Pete Alonso (1B/DH)

• The Fit: Pete Alonso is perhaps the most heavily rumored target. A five-time All-Star, Alonso has a career average of 42 home runs per 162 games.⁷ The Red Sox have not had a right-handed hitter hit 34 home runs since J.D. Martinez in 2019, making Alonso an ideal fit.⁸

• The Buzz: MLB Network’s Jon Morosi recently called the Red Sox the "strongest contender of anyone" to sign the former Met.⁹ Alonso could play first base while Triston Casas (recovering from a knee injury) is eased back in, and then potentially shift to designated hitter, providing immense lineup flexibility.¹⁰

2. The Familiar Face: Alex Bregman (3B)

• The Fit: Bregman, who spent a portion of 2025 with the Red Sox before hitting free agency, is a known quantity and a beloved clubhouse presence. He’s an established middle-of-the-order bat who addresses the team's need at third base.

• The Rumor: Insider reports suggest a reunion with Bregman "remains on the table." Bringing him back would solidify the hot corner and provide a valuable leadership presence for the young core, including Marcelo Mayer and Roman Anthony.¹¹

3. The Elite DH: Kyle Schwarber (DH)¹²

• The Fit: Schwarber is a pure offensive force, leading the majors in RBIs (132) and finishing second in home runs (56) in 2025. While he is primarily a designated hitter, his offensive numbers are too loud to ignore, and the Red Sox have the luxury of a dedicated DH spot.

• The Question: His DH-only status limits roster flexibility, but if the goal is to add an immense, top-of-the-lineup bat, Schwarber fits the bill perfectly.¹³

4. The International Wildcard: Kazuma Okamoto (1B)¹⁴

• The Fit: The recently posted Japanese infielder, Kazuma Okamoto, presents an intriguing, potentially high-upside alternative.¹⁵ He is a right-handed hitting first baseman who offers a significant power profile and a strong defensive glove. He is considered a strong fit for the Red Sox's specific positional needs.

---

💰 The Financial Reality

The Red Sox appear willing to spend aggressively this offseason, a welcome signal for a frustrated fanbase. Reports indicate the club is ready to spend beyond the $244 million luxury tax threshold for the 2026 season.¹⁶

Breslow has been aggressive in his first full offseason, trading for Crochet last winter and now adding Gray.¹⁷ The pursuit of an impact bat is the final, crucial step in demonstrating the organization's commitment to returning to title contention.

The successful acquisition of Sonny Gray was merely the overture; the next few weeks will determine if the Red Sox can land the offensive superstar capable of making their 2026 lineup a true juggernaut.